Microbiology: microbial genetics
Transformation vs transduction vs conjugation: how bacteria share genes, with a quiz
Bacteria don't have sex, but they still swap genes, and they do it three ways. They can pick up loose DNA (transformation), get DNA delivered by a virus (transduction), or have it passed to them through direct contact with another cell (conjugation). Exams love asking you to tell these apart from a short lab story. This guide gives you three questions that sort any story, then fifteen cases to practice on.
Practice this in the app: the Microbial Genetics chapter has questions with the reason behind each answer. Chapters 1 and 11 are free with no login. This chapter opens with the 3-day free trial (email only, no card).
Try a practice problem nowShort on time? Jump to the 15-case practice quiz. Every answer choice has its own explanation.
Vertical vs horizontal gene transfer
Vertical gene transfer is ordinary inheritance. A bacterium copies its chromosome and splits in two (binary fission), so each daughter cell gets the parent's genes. Genes move down the family tree, from one generation to the next.
Horizontal gene transfer (HGT) is sideways. A cell gets genes from another cell that is not its parent. The other cell can be the same species, a different species, or already dead. That's why one resistant strain can pass resistance to its neighbors in hours instead of waiting for a lucky mutation.
The DNA a cell picks up does not automatically stay. It sticks around only if it is either:
- swapped into the chromosome by recombination (this needs a matching stretch of DNA, so it works best between close relatives), or
- a plasmid that can copy itself on its own.
A memory hook
- Transformation: DNA is taken up from the surroundings.
- Transduction: DNA is delivered by a phage, a virus that infects bacteria.
- Conjugation: DNA is passed by contact, cell to cell.
Three questions that sort any case
Exam stories nearly always hide one of three clues. Ask these in order and you'll rarely get one wrong.
Does DNase in the medium stop the transfer?
DNase is an enzyme that chops up loose DNA. If adding it stops the transfer, the DNA was naked and exposed, so it's transformation. In transduction the DNA hides inside a phage protein coat. In conjugation it goes straight from one cell into the other. DNase can't reach it in either case.
Do the cells have to touch?
The classic test is a U-shaped tube with a filter in the middle that lets fluid through but not bacteria. If the filter stops the transfer, the cells needed contact, so it's conjugation. Free DNA and phages are small enough to pass the filter.
Is a phage involved?
If the DNA rides in a virus particle (a lysate, a “filterable agent” that DNase can't touch), it's transduction. Then ask a follow-up: can any gene move, or only genes next to where the phage sits in the chromosome? That tells you generalized or specialized.
Transformation: taking up naked DNA
When bacteria die and burst, bits of their DNA float around. Some bacteria can grab those bits, pull them inside, and use them. That's transformation.
Competence: the “ready to take up DNA” state
A cell that can bind and take up outside DNA is called competent. Some species are naturally competent, including Streptococcus pneumoniae, Bacillus subtilis, Haemophilus influenzae and Neisseria. Even in these species, competence is usually a temporary state the cell switches on, for example when cells get crowded or stressed. While it's on, the cell makes surface proteins that grab DNA and pull it inside.
Other bacteria, like E. coli, aren't naturally good at this. In the lab we make them competent on purpose, with calcium chloride and a quick heat shock or with an electric pulse (electroporation). That's how plasmids get into cells in cloning labs.
Once inside, a chromosome fragment has to be swapped into the chromosome by recombination, or it is broken down. A plasmid can be taken up whole and copy itself.
The history you need: Griffith, then Avery
- Griffith (1928) worked with Streptococcus pneumoniae. The smooth (S) strain has a capsule and killed mice. The rough (R) strain has no capsule and didn't. Heat-killed S alone didn't kill mice. But heat-killed S mixed with live R did, and live S bacteria came back out of the dead mice. Something from the dead S cells had transformed R cells into capsule-making S cells.
- Avery, MacLeod and McCarty (1944) purified that “transforming principle” and showed it was DNA. Enzymes that destroy protein or RNA left it working. DNase destroyed it. That's the original DNase test, and it's still the fingerprint of transformation.
Transduction: a phage delivers bacterial DNA by mistake
A bacteriophage (phage) normally packs its own genome into its protein head. Transduction happens when it packs bacterial DNA instead, or alongside its own, and then injects that DNA into the next cell it infects. Here's a quick refresher on the two phage life cycles, since each kind of transduction comes from one of them:
- Lytic cycle: the phage takes over, makes many copies of itself, and bursts (lyses) the cell.
- Lysogenic cycle: a temperate phage inserts its genome into the bacterial chromosome as a prophage and gets copied quietly with the cell. Later, stress such as UV light can induce it: the prophage cuts itself out and switches to the lytic cycle.
Generalized transduction
When: during a lytic cycle.
What goes wrong: the phage breaks the host chromosome into pieces, and a random piece gets packed into a phage head by accident.
What moves: any bacterial gene, each one at low frequency. The particle carries bacterial DNA only, so it can't start a productive phage cycle.
Classic phages: P1 in E. coli, P22 in Salmonella.
Specialized transduction
When: after a lysogenic phase, when the prophage is induced to leave.
What goes wrong: the prophage cuts itself out sloppily and takes a piece of the bacterial DNA right next to it.
What moves: only genes next to the phage's insertion site.
Classic example: phage lambda inserts between the gal and bio genes of E. coli, so it carries gal or bio and almost nothing else.
Don't mix this up with lysogenic conversion. In lysogenic conversion, the phage's own genes change the host. Diphtheria toxin, cholera toxin and botulinum toxin genes all come from phages this way. Transduction moves bacterial genes from the phage's previous host.
Conjugation: cell-to-cell contact, F+, Hfr and F'
In conjugation, a donor cell copies DNA straight into a recipient it is touching. In E. coli the instructions for doing this are on the F plasmid (F for fertility). F carries the tra (transfer) genes, including the genes for the F pilus (sex pilus). This thin appendage grabs a recipient and pulls the two cells together. Many gram-positive bacteria use sticky surface proteins (adhesins) instead of a pilus. Either way, conjugation only goes one way, from donor to recipient. It's not reproduction, and no new cell is made.
- F+ cell: has a free F plasmid, so it can be a donor.
- F− cell: has no F, so it can only be a recipient.
Here are the three crosses you'll be asked about.
F+ × F−
The F plasmid is nicked and one strand slides into the recipient. Both cells then build the missing partner strand, so each ends up with a complete F.
Result: two F+ cells. The recipient's chromosome is basically unchanged, because the plasmid is all that moved.
Hfr × F−
Sometimes F inserts itself into the chromosome. That cell is called Hfr (high frequency of recombination). When it conjugates, transfer starts partway through the inserted F and then keeps going into the chromosome, dragging chromosomal genes into the recipient in a fixed order. Moving the whole E. coli chromosome takes about 100 minutes, and the cells almost always break apart well before that.
Result: the recipient usually stays F−. The rest of F, including the transfer genes, would come in last, and the mating breaks before it gets there. The recipient does pick up donor chromosomal genes, which can be swapped in by recombination. That's why Hfr strains give lots of recombinants.
F' × F−
When an integrated F cuts back out sloppily, it can take a chunk of nearby chromosome with it. That plasmid is an F' (F-prime), for example F' lac.
Result: the recipient becomes F' and gets those extra chromosomal genes on the plasmid. If it already had its own copy, it now has two of that stretch, which makes it a partial diploid (merodiploid).
Comparison table
| Feature | Transformation | Transduction | Conjugation |
|---|---|---|---|
| What is transferred | Naked DNA fragments or plasmids from the surroundings | Bacterial DNA packed inside a phage head | Plasmid DNA (F, R plasmids), or chromosome from an Hfr |
| Cell-to-cell contact needed? | No | No | Yes (pilus or adhesins) |
| Stopped by DNase in the medium? | Yes | No (the capsid protects it) | No (DNA never leaves the cells) |
| Phage involved? | No | Yes | No |
| Passes a bacteria-proof filter? | Yes | Yes | No |
| Donor must be alive? | No (DNA from dead, burst cells works) | No (the donor is usually killed by the phage) | Yes |
| Recipient needs | To be competent | A receptor the phage can bind | To be F− (or another recipient type) |
| Classic example | Griffith's S. pneumoniae; plasmids into lab E. coli | P1 or P22 (generalized); lambda (specialized) | F plasmid, Hfr strains, R plasmids |
Why horizontal gene transfer matters: resistance and virulence
- Antibiotic resistance spreads sideways. Resistance genes often sit on R plasmids, which can carry several resistance genes at once plus the genes needed for conjugation. One conjugation can make a recipient resistant to several drugs in one step, even if it's a different species. For example, plasmids carrying carbapenemase genes move between hospital gut bacteria such as Klebsiella and E. coli.
- Transposons help. These “jumping genes” can hop a resistance gene from the chromosome onto a plasmid. Once it's on a conjugative plasmid, it can travel. The hop itself is called transposition. It happens inside one cell, so on its own it isn't horizontal gene transfer.
- Antibiotics select for resistance. A drug suppresses sensitive cells, letting resistant cells spread. Resistance can arise by mutation or gene transfer; the drug does not directly deliver a resistance plasmid.
- Virulence moves too. Phages bring toxin genes through lysogenic conversion (diphtheria, cholera, botulinum toxins). Plasmids can carry toxins, capsule genes and adhesion factors. Griffith's experiment was literally a virulence gene moving by transformation.
Common exam traps
- “DNase-resistant” does not mean transduction automatically.
- Conjugation is DNase-resistant too. Use the filter or contact clue to choose between them. Only transformation is DNase-sensitive.
- Transduction vs transformation
- Both work through a filter. The difference is the package: transduction DNA is inside a phage, so DNase can't touch it.
- Generalized vs specialized
- Generalized = lytic, random piece, any gene. Specialized = induced prophage, sloppy excision, only genes next to the insertion site. If the story says “only gal and bio,” think lambda and specialized.
- F+ vs Hfr
- An F+ donor turns the recipient F+ but rarely moves chromosomal genes. An Hfr donor moves chromosomal genes but rarely turns the recipient into anything other than F−.
- Competence vs conjugation
- Competence is about taking up free DNA (transformation). It has nothing to do with the F plasmid or pili. An F− cell doesn't need to be competent to receive DNA by conjugation.
- Lysogenic conversion vs transduction
- The toxin gene in lysogenic conversion belongs to the phage. Transduction moves the previous host's genes.
- Transposition and transfection
- Transposition moves DNA within one cell's genome. Transfection usually means putting DNA into eukaryotic cells. Neither one is among the three classic bacterial routes.
Four worked cases, step by step
Case A: the DNase test
Setup. Live S. pneumoniae without a capsule are mixed with a cell-free extract from encapsulated cells. A few encapsulated colonies grow. A second tube gets the same extract treated with DNase first, and no encapsulated colonies grow. A third tube gets extract treated with a protease, and encapsulated colonies grow.
- What moved? The ability to make a capsule, which is a gene.
- Was a living donor present? No, the extract is cell-free. That rules out conjugation.
- Did DNase stop it? Yes. The DNA was exposed in the medium. Transduction DNA would have been protected inside a capsid.
- Did protease stop it? No. So the active ingredient isn't protein. (That also argues against a phage, whose coat is protein.)
Answer: transformation. This is the Avery, MacLeod and McCarty logic.
Check: transformation is the only route in the comparison table that DNase stops and that works with no living donor and no phage. All three clues agree.
Case B: generalized or specialized?
Setup. Lysate X came from a lytic infection. It moves leu, thr, lac, trp and his, each at a similar low frequency. Lysate Y came from UV-inducing an E. coli strain that carries a prophage between gal and bio. It moves gal and bio but never trp or lac.
- Is a phage involved in both? Yes, both are phage lysates. So both are transduction.
- Lysate X: many unrelated genes from all over the chromosome, made during a lytic cycle. Random packaging fits.
- Lysate Y: only the two genes flanking the prophage site, made after induction. Sloppy excision fits.
Answer: X is generalized transduction (like P1). Y is specialized transduction (like lambda).
Check: if Y were generalized, trp and lac would show up at roughly the same low rate as gal. They never do, so Y can only be specialized.
Case C: reading an interrupted-mating experiment
Setup. An Hfr strain is mixed with an F− strain, and samples are shaken apart in a blender at different times. Donor genes first appear in recipients at these times: azi 9 min, tonA 11 min, lac 18 min, gal 25 min.
- Order the genes by entry time: 9 < 11 < 18 < 25, so the order from the origin is azi – tonA – lac – gal.
- Gaps between them (map distance in minutes): 11 − 9 = 2, 18 − 11 = 7, 25 − 18 = 7. So lac to gal is 7 minutes.
- Blended at 15 minutes: only genes entering by 15 minutes can have arrived, so that's azi and tonA. lac needs 18.
- Blended at 20 minutes: azi, tonA and lac. gal still needs 25.
- Are the recipients F+? No. The rest of F comes last, after about 100 minutes for the whole chromosome, so the recipients stay F−.
Check: 2 + 7 + 7 = 16, which matches gal minus azi (25 − 9 = 16). The gaps add up.
Case D: three crosses side by side
Setup. Each donor is lac+ and each recipient is lac− and F−. What does a typical recipient look like after mating?
| Cross | Recipient's F status | Gets donor lac+? | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| F+ (lac on chromosome) × F− | F+ | Rarely | Only the plasmid moves. |
| Hfr × F− | Stays F− | Often, if lac enters early | Chromosome moves in order; the rest of F comes last. |
| F' lac × F− | F' | Yes, on the plasmid | The plasmid itself carries lac. |
Check: in each row, the F status follows what physically moved. A whole plasmid makes the recipient F+ or F'. A piece of chromosome doesn't change its F status.
Practice quiz: 15 cases
Choose an answer and press Check. You'll see why that choice is right or wrong. Show worked solution opens the full reasoning, with an explanation for every option. Your first-try score updates after each checked case. Nothing is saved or sent anywhere.
Worked solution for case 1
Answer: transformation. Free DNA, no donor cells, no phage, and DNase blocks it.
- Transformation (correct): the DNA is loose in the extract and DNase destroys it. B. subtilis is naturally competent.
- Generalized transduction: there's no phage, and DNA inside a phage head would be safe from DNase.
- Conjugation: needs living donor cells touching the recipients. The extract has none.
- Specialized transduction: needs a prophage to be induced. There's no phage here at all.
Worked solution for case 2
Answer: transduction. It passes the filter, resists DNase, and uses a phage. This is essentially Zinder and Lederberg's 1952 discovery of transduction in Salmonella.
- Transformation: free DNA does pass a filter, but DNase would have stopped it.
- Transduction (correct): the phage carries the DNA through the filter inside its protein head, where DNase can't reach it.
- Conjugation: the filter keeps the cells from touching, so conjugation can't happen.
- Vertical gene transfer: that's parent to daughter cell. These are two separate strains on opposite sides of a filter.
Worked solution for case 3
Answer: conjugation. It needs contact (the filter blocks it), resists DNase, and there's a pilus.
- Transformation: free DNA would cross the filter, and DNase would stop it. Neither is true here.
- Transduction: phages pass through the filter, so a filter wouldn't block transduction.
- Conjugation (correct): the appendage is an F (sex) pilus pulling the cells together for direct transfer.
- Transposition: DNA jumping around inside one cell. It doesn't move genes between cells by itself.
Worked solution for case 4
Answer: specialized transduction. When the prophage cut itself out sloppily, it took the genes on either side of its insertion site. This is the classic lambda example.
- Generalized transduction: random packaging would move trp and lac too, at similar low rates.
- Specialized transduction (correct): only the genes flanking the prophage move, and the transfer starts from an induced lysogen.
- Transformation: the agent is a phage lysate, and transformation could pick up any gene, not just two neighbors.
- Conjugation by an Hfr strain: a lysate has no living donor cells to make contact.
Worked solution for case 5
Answer: generalized transduction. It comes from a lytic cycle, and genes from different parts of the chromosome each move at a low rate.
- Specialized transduction: would be limited to genes next to one insertion site, and it starts from a prophage, not a lytic infection.
- Lysogenic conversion: that's the phage's own genes changing the host. These are bacterial genes from the previous host.
- Generalized transduction (correct): P1 sometimes packs a random chunk of host chromosome by mistake, so any marker can travel.
- Transformation: the DNA arrives inside phage particles, not as free DNA.
Worked solution for case 6
Answer: F+ and still lac−. An F+ donor typically moves the F plasmid without chromosomal genes. F+ × F− gives two F+ cells.
- Still F−, but lac+: that's the Hfr pattern, where chromosomal genes move but F doesn't finish.
- F+ and lac+: lac is on the donor's chromosome, which an F+ cell doesn't transfer.
- F+ and still lac− (correct): the recipient gets a copy of F, and its chromosome is untouched.
- Unchanged, donor becomes F−: the donor keeps its F. It sends one strand and rebuilds the other, so both cells end up F+.
Worked solution for case 7
Answer: F−. Transfer starts in the middle of the inserted F and drags chromosome after it. The rest of F, with the transfer genes, comes at the very end, roughly 100 minutes for E. coli. The cells almost never stay joined that long.
- F+: an Hfr's F is built into the chromosome, so no separate F plasmid moves.
- F− (correct): the recipient picks up donor chromosome genes like lac+ by recombination but not a complete F.
- Hfr: that would require the recipient to gain an integrated F factor, which does not usually happen in an Hfr cross.
- F': F' plasmids come from sloppy excision of an integrated F inside the donor, not from every Hfr mating.
Worked solution for case 8
Answer: A, B and C. Keep every gene with an entry time of 20 minutes or less: 5, 12 and 19 qualify, and 31 doesn't.
- A only: that would be right for a stop between 5 and 12 minutes. B (12) and C (19) also had time.
- A and B: C enters at 19 minutes, which is before the 20-minute stop.
- A, B and C (correct): 5, 12 and 19 are all 20 or less.
- A, B, C and D, F+: D needs 31 minutes, and the rest of F arrives much later than the 20-minute stop.
Worked solution for case 9
Answer: it becomes F' lac and a partial diploid for lac. The whole plasmid moves, and the lac genes come with it.
- Stays F−, lac+: that's the Hfr outcome. Here the lac genes travel on a plasmid that moves whole.
- Hfr: that would need F to insert into the recipient's chromosome. Receiving an F' doesn't do that.
- F+ but lac−: the lac genes are part of this plasmid, so they can't be left behind.
- F' lac, partial diploid (correct): it now has two copies of the lac region, one mutant on the chromosome and one working copy on F'.
Worked solution for case 10
Answer: conjugation of an R plasmid. Two species carry the same plasmid, and it has transfer (pilus) genes. That's the signature of plasmid spread by conjugation.
- Point mutation: a chromosomal mutation wouldn't give E. coli the identical plasmid that Klebsiella has.
- Conjugation of an R plasmid (correct): this plasmid carries a resistance gene plus the machinery to pass itself on, even across species.
- Antibiotic switched on a gene: antibiotics select for resistant cells that already have the gene. They don't create or install it.
- Vertical inheritance: vertical means parent to daughter cell of the same lineage. Klebsiella can't be the parent of E. coli.
Worked solution for case 11
Answer: competent cells can take up free DNA. Competence belongs to transformation, and the F plasmid belongs to conjugation.
- Cells carrying a prophage: those are lysogens. That's the word for transduction and lysogeny, not competence.
- Correct as written: it mixes up two different mechanisms.
- Competent cells take up free DNA (correct): competence is a state with DNA-binding and uptake proteins. F encodes the pilus and transfer machinery, which is a different system.
- F− recipients: F− cells receive DNA through the donor's pilus. They don't need to be competent.
Worked solution for case 12
Answer: transformation by DNA from the dead S cells. Avery, MacLeod and McCarty (1944) later showed the active ingredient was DNA, because DNase destroyed it.
- Came back to life: heat-killed S injected alone didn't kill mice. The live R cells were needed.
- Conjugation: conjugation needs a living donor, and the S cells were dead.
- A phage: no phage was involved. The transforming activity was later destroyed by DNase, which wouldn't touch DNA inside a phage.
- Transformed by material from dead S (correct): R cells took up capsule genes and became S.
Worked solution for case 13
Answer: lysogenic conversion. The new trait comes from a phage gene, not from a gene of the phage's previous bacterial host.
- Generalized transduction: moves random bacterial DNA that was packed by mistake. The toxin gene here belongs to the phage.
- Specialized transduction: moves the previous host's genes next to the insertion site. Again, this gene is the phage's own.
- Lysogenic conversion (correct): a prophage's genes change the host's traits. Cholera toxin and botulinum toxin are other examples.
- Transformation: there's no free DNA. A phage infection did this.
Worked solution for case 14
Answer: no, it's transposition. Horizontal transfer means DNA moves between cells. Nothing has left this cell yet. If the plasmid is conjugative, though, the gene can now spread.
- Conjugation: needs a second cell. Only one cell is involved.
- No, transposition (correct): a transposon moved within one genome. That often comes right before resistance spreads by conjugation.
- Transformation: needs DNA taken up from outside the cell.
- Specialized transduction: needs a phage carrying DNA to another cell.
Worked solution for case 15
- Transformation: No, Yes, No. Free DNA needs no contact and no phage, and because it's exposed, DNase destroys it.
- Transduction: No, No, Yes. The phage carries the DNA, so no contact is needed. The capsid shields it from DNase.
- Conjugation: Yes, No, No. A pilus or adhesins join the cells, and the DNA passes directly inside, out of DNase's reach. No phage is involved.
Answer a case to start your score.
FAQ
What is the difference between transformation, transduction and conjugation?
All three move genes sideways between bacteria. In transformation a competent cell takes up naked DNA from its surroundings. In transduction a bacteriophage accidentally carries bacterial DNA from one cell to another. In conjugation a donor cell passes DNA, usually a plasmid, directly into a recipient it is touching through a pilus or adhesins.
Which gene transfer method is stopped by DNase?
Only transformation. The DNA is free in the medium, so DNase can destroy it. In transduction the DNA is protected inside the phage capsid, and in conjugation it passes directly from one cell into another.
What is the difference between generalized and specialized transduction?
Generalized transduction happens during a lytic cycle when a random piece of host DNA is packaged by mistake, so any gene can be moved. Specialized transduction happens when an integrated prophage is cut out imprecisely and carries only the bacterial genes next to its insertion site, such as gal or bio for phage lambda.
Why does the recipient usually stay F− in an Hfr cross?
In an Hfr cell the F plasmid is built into the chromosome. Transfer starts partway through F, then carries chromosomal genes in order, and the rest of F would arrive last. Moving the whole E. coli chromosome takes about 100 minutes, and mating almost always breaks before then.
Is bacterial conjugation a form of sexual reproduction?
No. Conjugation is a one-way transfer of DNA from a donor to a recipient. No new cell is made. Bacteria reproduce asexually by binary fission, which is vertical gene transfer.